In a moment of reflection on my life I came to an interesting life lesson characterized by the simple phrase "Don't know".
The lesson that I learned is simply this, that it is ok to not know everything and also if you don't know something it is alright to simply say "I don't know that".
For so many people, me before learning this, there has to be an answer to all questions and there must be a yes/no answer to all issues, grey areas or "don't knows" were either compromises or worse, denial of truth.
The "don't know" lesson is important to what my beloved rabbi calls the "census of the redeemed" or it's opposite "the census of hell".
Both in the Church and among the Jewish Missions culture the answer to the question of the eternal destiny of all people, including the Jewish People is a settled issue, that being all non-Yeshua believers are categorically in the "census of hell" and are without hope and without G-d in this world and in the next. This is a settled issue and anyone who is not ready to answer unequivocally that all Jews who do not/did not embrace Yeshua as Messiah are damned are somehow unfaithful to the Bible and to G-d and also that these people are or may be espousing "dual covenant" theology.
I think that it is important to realize that all knowledge of G-d's dealings are in His hands and though we are given some insight into G-d's work, there are things that we don't know and I will say the mystery of how G-d distributes the merit of Yeshua's death is one of those issues. We do know that all who come to eternal life enter by Yeshua's sacrifice and that by explicit faith trust in Yeshua there is assurance of atonement, but there is more to the issue of the atonement that I think we do not know fully in how and to whom this new life is distributed.
So then we can and in some cases must say "don't know" on some important issues knowing that there are areas where G-d has not fully revealed His full plan to us, yet know that He is in charge of all things and will do that which is right.

4 comments:
Saturday, October 13, 2007 9:35:00 PM
Hi Yochanan,
This is a good point.
I too have come to a realization that I don't know all things. It is all too common to be in the company of various religious folk that always have a definite answer for every matter.
For me, the concept of Mashiach and the total application of it is absolutely huge! I can not say that I completely grasp every element of it. It's good not to be alone...
Saturday, October 20, 2007 7:07:00 PM
I'm just interested to know where you personally, and the Hashivenu camp stand on this issue. I'm leaning towards Hashivenu in practice, but in theology I'm also very conservative and proud to be one. Not conservative Christian style, but conservative Jewish style. (And I'm sick of the knee-jerk reaction to anything Christian among Messianic and non-Messianic Jews.) Do you believe that the entire Bible is holy, inspired by God and infallible? Was the Torah given to Moses at Sinai, or was it written down by Moses him self and/or other writers? Is the Bible the word of God, or does it contain the word of God mixed with human opinion with lesser authority? (The latter perspective has opened up for liberal movements allowing same-sex marriage etc., separating between what they regard as "God's commandments" telling us to love and be faithful to our spouse, and what they choose/want to believe is a more human biased commandment prohobiting same-sex relations. That's just an example.)
Sunday, October 28, 2007 12:46:00 PM
anonymous,
i can only speak for myself, i am not an authorized spokesperson for hashivenu.
i believe that the Bible is inspired and infallible.
i do believe that moses received the torah at mt. sinai, though i will allow for the ending of the book of devarim's account of the death of moses being written by joshua.
Tuesday, November 11, 2008 8:05:00 AM
Good words.
Post a Comment